Your website was approved on the wrong screen.
Almost every business website gets approved on the wrong screen.
The sign-off happens in a conference room, on a big monitor, or on the designer’s laptop over good office Wi-Fi. That is where the meeting is. So that is the version the owner sees, the version everyone nods at, and the version the invoice gets paid against. Nobody in the room is being lazy. The process rewards looking right in the room.
Your customer is somewhere else. They are in a parking lot with one hand free and a weak signal. They tapped a link in a text, and their browser is keeping about a fifth of the screen for itself. The headline that looked calm on the monitor is sitting on top of the photo. The button is off the screen. The form wants them to pinch and zoom.
Agencies know this, which is why the deck always has a phone in it. Look closely at that phone. It is a picture. It is a tall, clean rectangle with no browser bars, no slow connection, and no thumb. A mockup of a phone proves the design fits inside a drawing of a phone.
Here is the test, and it takes four minutes. Pull out your own phone. Open your homepage in the browser, the way a stranger would. Without scrolling, can you tell what you sell and how to reach you? Now scroll slowly, top to bottom, and watch for anything that overlaps, jumps, or runs off the edge. Then fill out your own form with one thumb and send it.
Then ask your agency one question. Not whether they tested on a phone. Ask which phone, and which browser. A team that did the work answers in a second.
We rebuilt this site in October. It passed every check we ran on a laptop and every check we ran on a simulated phone. Then we opened it on an actual iPhone, scrolled once, and watched a label run straight into our own logo. Nothing had flagged it, because our test screen was taller than a real one. So we changed the order. The phone comes first now, at the height the browser really leaves you, and the laptop gets checked after.
The honest objection is that your analytics say most of your buyers are on desktop. For some businesses that is true. But analytics count visits, not decisions. Plenty of buyers get their first look on a phone, then come back on a laptop later, if the phone gave them a reason to. Anyone the phone lost never shows up in that second number. You are looking at the people who made it through.
Nobody buys from the version you approved.
Go look at the one they actually see.